The first Nazi: Erich Ludendorff – the man who made Hitler possible by Will Brownell and Denise Drace-Brownell with Alex Rovt - Book Review

About Marcus Fielding

Colonel Marcus Fielding was born and raised in Melbourne. He joined the Australian Army in 1983, graduated from the Royal Military College, Duntroon in December 1986, and was commissioned into the Royal Australian Engineers. He has held a variety of command, staff and instructional appointments and has served on operations in Pakistan, Afghanistan, Haiti, East Timor and Iraq. Colonel Fielding recently transferred from the full-time to part-time service with the Australian Army and is currently the President of MHHV and the President of the Camberwell RSL

General Erich Ludendorff was one of the most important military individuals of the last century, yet today, he is one of the least known. One of the top two German generals of World War I, Ludendorff manipulated and dominated not only his superior, General Paul von Hindenburg, but also Germany’s head of state, Kaiser Wilhelm II.

Duckworth Overlook: London; 2017; 288 pp.; ISBN 9780715652183 (paperback); RRP $21.99

Duckworth Overlook: London; 2017; 288 pp.; ISBN 9780715652183 (paperback); RRP $21.99

For several years, Ludendorff was the de facto dictator of Germany. Ludendorff not only directed all aspects of World War I, he refused all opportunities to make peace; he antagonised the Americans until they declared war; he sent Lenin into Russia to forge a revolution to shut down the Russian front; and then pushed for total military victory in 1918, in a rabid slaughter known as ‘The Ludendorff Offensive’. This savage man had staggering designs to build a gigantic state that would dwarf even the British Empire. A brilliant tactician and an abysmally poor politician and strategist, Ludendorff summed up the strengths and weaknesses of the German General Staff.

Shortly after Germany lost the War in 1918, Ludendorff created the murderous myth that Germany had lost this war only because Jews had conspired on the home front. He then wrote arguing maniacally about how Germans needed a new ‘total world war’ to redeem the Fatherland. He then aided Hitler’s new Nazi movement and then drifted ever further into the haze of right-wing conspiracy theories that poisoned the Weimar Republic.

The consequences of Ludendorff’s actions are mind boggling in their scale and reach. He could have ended World War I in 1916; by sending Lenin to St Petersburg he enabled the October Revolution to succeed and the Communist ideology to subsequently control billions of people for decades; his ‘stabbed in the back’ excuse ultimately became the basis for the Holocaust.
The title, ‘The First Nazi’, comes from the authors’ argument that Ludendorff was the source of a large part of the Nazi ideology and was an essential player in helping Hitler and the Nazi party rise to power. “Most analyses of World War II tend to begin with Hitler. And most people assume that Nazism began with that man. But it was Ludendorff who unleashed the social, military, and political forces that were keys to Hitler’s success” the authors argue.

The First Nazi is a fascinating read, opening a whole new window on the world wars and providing a chilling view of a man who had a profound impact on the 20th century. Throughout, the authors draw many broad-ranging insights that open a whole new window on the world wars and the German psyche at the time. “So it was that this miserable war began with the Schlieffen Plan, which could not work, collapsed with the Ludendorff Offensive, which could not succeed, closed with the Versailles Treaty, which could not be implemented, and culminated in a conspiracy legend against Jews, which could never be proven.” “…Germany was unbalanced between 1914 and 1945, and a case could be made that World Wars I and II were an insane continuum that started with the slow rise of Ludendorff as a de facto dictator by 1916 and ended with the suicide of Hitler in his pathetic bunker in 1945.”

Will Brownell, Ph.D., is an expert in European military history and the author of So Close to Greatness, the biography of William C. Bullitt, the first United States Ambassador to the Soviet Union. Denise Drace-Brownell is a technologist, inventor, and international business executive, educated at Columbia and Rutgers, as well as the Universities of Pennsylvania and Illinois.

The First Nazi contains a number of black and white photographs, a timeline of the Great War, biographical notes on the main characters, as well as comprehensive notes and an index.

First published in 2016, The First Nazi is a well-researched and very accessible book about a little-known chapter of history. The authors’ clear narrative and patient research succeed in connecting dots that have long been overlooked. It is highly recommended to readers of military and political history.

MHHV Members
Previous MHHV events